Softwater Mineral GH+
Salty Shrimp Softwater Mineral GH+ is a specialized variant designed for Caridina species that prefer slightly higher TDS levels. While similar to the more popular Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+, this formula
Product Overview
Salty Shrimp Softwater Mineral GH+ is a specialized variant designed for Caridina species that prefer slightly higher TDS levels. While similar to the more popular Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+, this formula produces a slightly different mineral profile that results in higher TDS readings at the same GH. It's particularly favored for Tiger shrimp and certain other Caridina that tolerate or prefer more mineral content in their water.
Detailed Review
Softwater Mineral GH+ is one of those products that exists for a specific niche. If you're keeping standard Crystal Red Shrimp or Taiwan Bees, you probably don't need it - Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+ is the standard choice. But for certain species that prefer a different mineral profile, this variant has its place. The key difference is that Softwater produces higher TDS at the same GH level compared to Bee Shrimp Mineral. This might sound minor, but some Caridina varieties - particularly Tigers and some wild-type Caridina - seem to prefer this profile. Quality-wise, it's identical to other Salty Shrimp products. German manufacturing, consistent results, complete dissolution, no effect on KH. If you trust Bee Shrimp Mineral, you can trust this variant. The challenge is determining if you actually need it. For most keepers, the standard Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+ is the right choice. Softwater Mineral is really only worth considering if you're keeping species that prefer higher TDS or if you've noticed your shrimp seem happier with more mineral content. If you're unsure, stick with Bee Shrimp Mineral - it works well for the vast majority of Caridina setups. Consider Softwater only if you have specific species requirements or experience suggesting higher TDS would benefit your colony.
Dosing Guide
Manufacturer Recommendation
Add approximately 3g per 10 liters (2.6 gallons) of RO water to achieve ~6 GH. Designed for species preferring slightly higher TDS than Bee Shrimp Mineral.
Community Consensus
Similar to Bee Shrimp GH+ but designed for species that prefer slightly higher TDS at the same GH. Some users report it works well for Tiger shrimp and some Caridina that tolerate higher mineral content. Less popular than Bee Shrimp Mineral.
Quick Dosing Reference
Approximate amounts for Softwater Mineral GH+ starting from 0 TDS RO water
| Target GH | Grams per Gallon | Grams per Liter |
|---|---|---|
| 4 dGH | 0.45g | 0.12g |
| 5 dGH | 0.56g | 0.15g |
| 6 dGH | 0.68g | 0.18g |
| 7 dGH | 0.79g | 0.21g |
Important Notes
- Always test your water after mixing and before adding to your tank
- TDS readings can vary based on your TDS meter calibration
- Dose to your target GH, not TDS, for best results
- Let water sit 10-15 minutes after mixing for accurate readings
Community Feedback
Community Consensus
A niche variant of Salty Shrimp's GH+ line designed for species that prefer slightly higher TDS. Less commonly used than Bee Shrimp Mineral but has a dedicated following among keepers of certain Caridina varieties. Same German quality as other Salty Shrimp products.
What Users Love
- Same quality as Bee Shrimp Mineral
- Good for Tiger shrimp and some Caridina
- Slightly higher TDS at same GH
- German manufacturing quality
- Consistent results
Common Concerns
- Confusing to differentiate from Bee Shrimp Mineral
- Less community documentation
- Smaller user base
- May be overkill for most Caridina
Notable Discussions
- Softwater vs Bee Shrimp Mineral comparison
- Tiger shrimp remineralizer discussions
- TDS vs GH optimization threads
Feedback aggregated from Reddit (r/shrimptank, r/Aquariums), The Planted Tank Forum, and other aquarium communities. Individual experiences may vary.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- Same German quality as Bee Shrimp Mineral
- Good for species preferring higher TDS
- Consistent batch-to-batch performance
- No effect on KH
- Works well for Tiger shrimp
- From trusted Salty Shrimp brand
Cons
- Niche product with smaller user base
- Confusing product differentiation
- Less community documentation
- May not be necessary for most keepers
Frequently Asked Questions
Both are GH+ only products for Caridina, but Softwater produces slightly higher TDS at the same GH level. This different mineral profile may benefit Tiger shrimp and some other Caridina that prefer more mineral content.
For standard Crystal Red Shrimp, most keepers use Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+. Softwater is typically reserved for Tiger shrimp or specific Caridina that prefer higher TDS.
No, like other Salty Shrimp GH+ products, it only raises GH without affecting KH. Your buffering substrate will continue maintaining low pH.
Use approximately 0.55-0.7g per gallon for 5-6 GH. This is slightly less than Bee Shrimp Mineral due to the different formulation. Always test after mixing.
Some species prefer more overall mineral content. Higher TDS at the same GH means additional minerals beyond just calcium and magnesium, which certain Caridina may benefit from.
Yes, it's a more niche product. It's available through the same retailers but may have less stock. If you can't find it locally, Bee Shrimp Mineral works well for most Caridina.
Alternative Products
Bee Shrimp Mineral GH+
Serious Caridina breeders who want the most reliable, consistent remineralizer for Crystal Red, Taiwan Bee, and other sensitive Caridina species.
Blue Wizard GH Conditioner
Caridina keepers looking for a quality GH+ option at a better price point than Salty Shrimp, especially those keeping Taiwan Bee varieties.
Remineraliz-P
US-based Caridina keepers looking for a quality GH+ product at a better price than imported alternatives, with good availability and reasonable shipping.
Track Your Remineralization with ShrimpKeeper
Use our built-in calculator to dose Softwater Mineral GH+ perfectly every time. Track your parameters and see trends over time.
Quick Specs
Yields per Gram
Target Ranges
Available Sizes
Best For
Keepers of Tiger shrimp or Caridina species that prefer slightly higher TDS levels at the same GH range as standard Bee Shrimp parameters.